MI5 expresses concern over Mandelson's file-sharing tactics

The police and UK intelligence services have appealed to the Government to drop plans to disconnect even the most persistent internet pirates for fear it would make it more difficult to catch criminals at work.

In the next Digital Economy Bill, Business Secretary, Lord Mandelson, has pledged he will put into force new measures to fight illegal file-sharing of music and films by cutting off the broadband connection of suspected offenders.

However, in an article published by The Times it was revealed both the national security services (including MI5 and MI6) and the UK police believe criminals will escape conviction by turning to encryption. This in turn will increase both the costs and the workload for those responsible for monitoring internet traffic. One source informed the paper: “The spooks hate it. They think it's only going to make monitoring more difficult.”

Internet service providers such as BT and Carphone Warehouse have been very vocal in showing disapproval to Mandelson's suggestion pirates should be disconnected from the internet without trial. They have estimated the decision to approve technical measures to monitor and punish illegal downloaders could in turn raise the price of broadband for the average consumer by £2 a month. Consumer groups concerned about customers' rights to privacy have also criticised the plans.

Public opinion shows little support for Mandelson's proposals. In a YouGov poll released yesterday almost 70 per cent shared the view anyone suspected of illegal downloading should have a right to a trail in court before being cut off from their internet service.